Quantcast The Cauldron
College Media Network

Book Reviews

Sairah Zaidi

Issue date: 8/25/08 Section: Arts & Entertainment
  • Print
  • Email
  • Page 1 of 1


Breaking Dawn
by Stephenie Meyer.
MT Books/Little Brown. 756 pp. $22.99
(Warning: contains spoilers!)

I was venturing into unfamiliar territory when I was assigned to read this fourth and final novel of the bestselling vampire/romance "Twilight" series by Stephenie Meyer. The story is replete with werewolf/vampire rivalry, fancy cars and parties and honeymoons, shape-shifting and mind-reading, oddly disturbing sexual tension, and a rather appalling description of the pregnancy of the protagonist Bella. If that sounds like your cup of tea, then full steam ahead - but I'm guessing that Breaking Dawn falls short of the first three novels which drew in millions of readers.

The novel is divided into three books, with the first and last told from the perspective of the young, clumsy and danger-prone Bella Swan and the middle book narrated by her werewolf friend, Jacob Black. Bella Swan and her vampire lover Edward Cullen finally marry, and a rather interesting honeymoon ensues - this is where the odd sexual dynamic surfaces. She becomes pregnant and the vampire-hybrid child drains her to almost the point of death, cracking her ribs and prompting the realization that it requires blood. Bella obliges and feels better. The proxy conflict between the jealous Jacob and husband Edward is reminiscent of junior high, and meanwhile another vampire tribe is in uproar because they have mistakenly heard that Bella's child is an immortal child (If you want to find out more about these creatures and 'vegetarian-vampires,' buy the book).

I'm all for fantasy and magical creatures, being an avid Harry Potter fan myself, but I fail to see why these novels have become so popular. The quality of writing is mediocre (as indicated by the final line of the book, "And then we continued blissfully into this small but perfect piece of our forever") and the characters seem to play into stereotypically (yet somehow also oddly bizarre) sexist roles. Loyal fans have already bought over a million copies, so perhaps this author is just an unappreciative outsider - read it for yourself and see.

The Way of the World: A Story of Truth and Hope in an Age of Extremism by Ron Suskind.
Harper Collins. 415 pp. $27.95.

From the Pulitzer Prize-winning author of The Price of Loyalty and The One Percent Doctrine comes another sweeping indictment of the Bush Administration's national security policies and the false pretenses under which it led the nation to war.

The most explosive accusation is, as covered by the media frequently, that the White House ordered the CIA to forge a document linking Saddam Hussein to Al Qaeda before going to war in 2003. He also describes how information from a top Iraqi intelligence official, which refuted the existence of any weapons of mass destruction, was ignored.

A deliberate attempt to maximize executive power and reduce accountability was made in particular by Dick Cheney, and Suskind traces this evolution. The White House has been quick to dismiss the claims, saying that Suskind "has chosen to dwell in the netherworld of bizarre conspiracy theories," a response that is interesting considering that the notion that the Administration deliberately misled the American public into going to war is quite uncontroversial, and certainly not bizarre.

Beyond the insights into the actions and policies of the administration, Suskind describes various people around the world, such as a UN refugee commissioner in Darfur, attempting to restore human values and moral sensibility in an age where the United States has failed to do so. He waxes a tad idealistic at times, and the connection between these people and the central claim of his book is arguably quite a stretch - but for anyone hoping to gain insight into the inner-workings of a highly secretive and unaccountable administration, Suskind delivers the goods.


Page 1 of 1

Article Tools

Viewing Comments 1 - 10 of 18

jane

posted 8/25/08 @ 4:27 PM EST

im english and i still think that twilight is better than harry potter!!!
and im also a fan of harry
they are just different, ok??

mari

posted 8/25/08 @ 5:08 PM EST

of course twiglight is wayyy better,,,,harry potter
become famous because it was different and it impact
everyone because we werent use to such an imagination
but twilight is special because is so diferent
and at the same time u can related to it. (Continued…)

(1 reply)   Details   Reply to this comment

hailee

posted 8/25/08 @ 5:09 PM EST

as an avid harry potter fan and twilighter i dont see why you have such an issue with this book.. it appeals to so many people because it's real.. the tension and the love is all apart of life. (Continued…)

Lena

posted 8/25/08 @ 6:04 PM EST

I really do not see your point. At all.
Twilight is an amazing series, and MUCH better than harrypotter, in my opinion. it is much more believable and creative. (Continued…)

Jed

posted 8/25/08 @ 7:23 PM EST

To Sairah Zaidi,

A book reviewer is supposed to be objective, while personal preferences cannot be avoided, it seems you have missed the point of the book. (Continued…)

Monique

posted 8/25/08 @ 8:15 PM EST

The book rocks! You may not see why people love it so much, but you dont need to down the Twilighter's vibe. :) Breaking Dawn was great, and Stephenie Meyer stayed true to herself and what she wanted of the book even though there were a lot of expectations on her from fans and critics. (Continued…)

kate

posted 8/25/08 @ 8:53 PM EST

I´m a Harry Potter fan and I agree that HP is better than Twilight in writing, but they are both great and diferent, very diferent. Harry Potter is more creative and Twilight is super romantic. (Continued…)

Stephanie

posted 8/25/08 @ 9:46 PM EST

I agree. However in the Twilight Saga's defence, the first three books are pretty good. SM just bombed out on this one.

Cammyway

posted 8/25/08 @ 10:51 PM EST

WHAT!!! Twilight's awesome! It's definitely way better than Harry Potter. Breaking Dawn was the BEST!!!

Zeeebras

posted 8/25/08 @ 11:27 PM EST

okay.. first of all. i love this series..
more than i do twilight. but i hate that this reviewer
had to say stephenie's writing is mediocre.
i think she's better than most authors. (Continued…)

Post a Comment

  • NOTE: Email address will not be published

Type your comment below (html not allowed)

  I understand posting spam or other comments that are unrelated to this article will cause my comment to be flagged for deletion and possibly cause my IP address to be permanently banned from this server.

Advertisement

Advertisement